Jump to content

Scott J. Promish

Members
  • Posts

    84
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Posts posted by Scott J. Promish

  1. Further information: The copyright page lists a standard ISBN and a direct market exclusive ISBN.  Since I bought my copy at a comic book store, I would assume that is the direct market edition, but that is how Book 1 Hardcover is listed.

    https://atomicavenue.com/atomic/item/1390362/1/Somna-Book-1-Hardcover

    Is variation A a softcover?  If so, why isn't it just Book 1?

    https://atomicavenue.com/atomic/item/1406836/1/Somna-Book-1-Variation-A

    Can you tell me what ISBNs you have for the two collected editions already in the database?

     

  2. I just picked up the hardcover collected edition of Becky Cloonan and Tula Lotay's Somna and I'm not sure how to designate it in my CB.

    The Book #1 Hardcover is the direct market edition with a different cover.

    Book #1 Variation A has a similar cover, but the colors are different, and mine doesn't have the DSTLRY logo in the upper right corner. I wonder if that might be a preliminary cover in CB/AA.  The book just came out and mine is a first printing.  I've attached a scan of my copy below.

    I cannot compare the ISBN as my CB is not up to date.  But the ISBN on my book is 9781962265010.

    So I need to know if I should replace the Variation A with my cover, or create a new issue.  If the latter, what designation should I give it?

    img20240718_11054298.jpg

  3. I have 2024 Archive, which I just updated recently.  Now you mention it I do remember that function--only problem is, it never downloaded the larger cover when I clicked on it.

    My subscription only lapsed recently, but when I renew again I'll see what happens I guess...

  4. My subscription ran out recently, but this was an issue even when I was current.  It seems almost as if a majority of the covers in my CB are tiny (no bigger than the thumbnail.)  Covers for very well-known, mainstream comics, that even if CB did only have a tiny image at one time, would have been replaced many times over by users if not HC themselves.  Take a look at Amazing Spider-Man, for example.  Very few covers are not tiny.

    Some covers display large but are such poor resolution that they are probably meant to be tiny as well.

    I feel like this is an issue that started in the last year or so, though my sense of time is not great.

  5. I have the hardcover collection of this published by Dover with the same ISBN & barcode that are in the system under Border Worlds (Vol. 1) Book 1, but the cover differs from the existing image in that it doesn't have any of the stuff at the bottom (publisher logo, promotional text), just the author & title at top and the image.  My copy does not state an edition, but I doubt there were multiple printings of this.  Should I scan my cover and upload it as a substitute, or create a new record?

  6. ComicBase has it as Saga of Crystar, the Crystal Warrior but it should be The Sage of Crystar, Crystal Warrior.  I sent an email so presumably the incorrect title will be removed eventually. (I currently have both variations, probably due to an update that re-added the wrong one.)

    Edit: I see that you have mentioned it in the cover scan maintenance thread, so it looks like it was done. Thanks.

×
×
  • Create New...